Episode 3: How to Build a College List: Reach, Target & Likely Schools Explained
Building a college list shouldn't cause panic; it should build confidence. In this episode of Drop In, Josh and Lisa break down how to build a college list based on fit, not just names.
Most families start with a "panic list" of dozens of schools thrown on with no real strategy. Josh and Lisa reveal the framework they use with every Decision Drop family to turn that chaos into a focused, confidence-building college list built on reach, target, and likely schools.
You'll learn:
Why "safety school" might be the wrong term, and what to say instead
Why fit matters more than reputation, and how to find a campus where your student will thrive
How many schools actually belong on a balanced college list (it's more personal than formulaic)
How to weigh campus size, location, and major availability in your college list strategy
Why financial fit and merit aid deserve a seat at the table early, not after acceptances arrive
Perfect for parents and students feeling overwhelmed by a college list with no plan behind it, or anyone ready to stop playing the numbers game and start building a list with real, confident options.
The name on the diploma doesn't guarantee happiness. Fit does.
New episodes of Drop In drop every week, subscribe so you don't miss the next one.
Read more about building a college list here.
Ready to build your student's college list the right way? Schedule a free intro call: decisiondrop.com/contact
#collegeadmissions #collegelist #collegeapplications
🎙️ Also available on: Apple Podcasts · iHeartRadio ·Amazon Music 🔈
Josh: Every week we drop the noise and drop some knowledge.
Lisa: Drop the stress. Welcome to Drop In, the College Admissions podcast by Decision Drop. If you want to learn more about our services or have Josh and I help you and your family personally through this process, please head over to decisiondrop.com.
Josh: I'm Josh.
Lisa: I'm Lisa. So let's go.
Josh: Okay, Lisa, episode three — we are back yet again. This week we're going to talk about a topic that might be the thing that saves families a lot of unnecessary stress.
Lisa: Yeah, because I think this is the one that actually really starts the process, right? Before essays, before applications, before any of it — the college list.
Josh: Yeah, which sounds very simple. Just make a list of colleges, right?
Lisa: Right. Except it's absolutely not that simple. And I think the way most families approach building this list — I'm going to be honest — I think it's really backwards.
Josh: It can be. So we're going to spend some time today walking students and families through how to build a college list in a way that we feel actually works.
Lisa: Yeah, a list that actually gives your kiddo options. It gives them room to breathe, but I think most importantly, it gives them confidence. And I think that's what we're going to do today.
Josh: All right, let's get into it. We're going to start the conversation with what we see constantly when we're meeting with students and families — and it's something we want to push back on right up front: the panic list.
Lisa: Okay, the panic list. This is a list that usually shows up when the student comes to us in October of senior year, when applications are due and the stress is super high. Josh, you've seen it, I've seen it, we've talked about this a lot. It's literally: they just start adding schools. Schools their friends have applied to, schools that are making a hot run on the college football scene — we've seen that before. Every school. All schools. "I'll just apply to twenty schools and see what happens."
Josh: Yeah, the anxiety is real, the fear of not getting in anywhere is real. But what we want to emphasize to students and parents is that just applying to twenty random schools isn't actually a good strategy. To us, that shows a student who hasn't started early enough and isn't putting any intentionality into the process itself.
Lisa: And I think what really makes this panic list happen — let's say it's twenty schools — that means twenty more potential supplements, twenty more application fees, twenty more student portals to keep track of, and your student is completely burned out by the time December even rolls around.
Josh: When you say it like that, it doesn't sound great. So what we want to do is talk about what a good list actually looks like. The basic framework has three pieces to it: a reach list, a target list, and a likely list.
Lisa: Right. Let's start with reach schools. Those are schools where your student is basically below the academic profile of the typically admitted student. Getting in is possible — Josh and I would say nothing is impossible — but it might not be probable based on the numbers alone. Think of it like a zero to twenty-five percent chance of getting into a reach school.
Josh: And target schools are schools where the student's profile falls right in the middle of that school's admitted range. The student is a competitive applicant, but admission is never guaranteed.
Lisa: Right, so I'd say that's about a fifty percent chance. Then you have likely — I like to call it a "foundation likely" school, because I want you to actually like this school, it's a foundation. Sometimes it's called a safety school, but I can tell you that most college counselors — and Josh and I definitely — do not like that word.
Josh: Yeah, we really don't.
Lisa: I don't think anything is "safe" anymore. That's why we like foundation likely — because these are schools where, looking at the profile, the student is typically above the admitted range. So admission is highly probable. Not guaranteed, because nothing is guaranteed in this process, let's be honest. But highly probable. Think of it as around a seventy-five percent chance.
Josh: Since you brought up safety, can we take a second to talk about why we don't love that word?
Lisa: Please, please, please.
Josh: For us, the word "safety" implies a fallback, a consolation prize. It creates a framework that, even unintentionally, allows families to disrespect some of those schools before the student ever sets foot on campus. And if the student does end up going to that school, they could arrive feeling like a failure. That's not a great way to start a college career.
Lisa: No — because every school on a student's list should be a school they genuinely and enthusiastically want to attend. That's the baseline. If a student won't be happy there, why is it on the list? Why spend the brain space on another application and another supplemental if you don't actually like the school? There are a thousand schools you could get into. If you don't like it, don't apply to it.
Josh: And a thousand schools is a big number, which leads to a question we constantly get from students and families: how many schools should be on the list?
Lisa: Great question, Josh. Drumroll, please — enough to give you real options, but not so many that the process becomes unmanageable.
Josh: For most students, somewhere between eight and twelve schools is the sweet spot. That might include maybe three reach schools, four or five target schools, and two or three likely schools.
Lisa: And what's most important is that you think of that breakdown as a starting point, not a formula, because every student's situation is different. A student with a very strong profile relative to the schools they're interested in might have more reaches on their list. Or a student with a specific major might have a smaller list overall, because their options are naturally more limited.
I want to be really clear: that breakdown is a starting point, not a formula. We treat every student differently because every student is uniquely themselves. If you're happy with a couple of your foundation likely schools, the world is your oyster — shoot for the stars, add as many reaches as you like. Just know that reaches can come with a "no" later in the year.
Josh: Right. And really, the list should be built around the student — their academic profile, their preferences. That should be the foundation of building the list. Which brings us to something we think is the most important, and most undervalued, part of building a list. It's a little bit of a cheesy word, but we like it: fit.
Lisa: Ooh. Say more.
Josh: Fit has become kind of a cheesy word in college admissions vernacular, but to us it's not vague at all. It's not some "woo-woo" feeling you get from looking at a campus on social media. Fit is the overlap between who a student actually is — their learning style, personality, values, interests outside the classroom — and what a school actually offers in terms of culture, curriculum, size, location, and community.
Lisa: Right, and I think this is where families really go wrong sometimes — they start building a list entirely on rankings and reputation. What's the bumper sticker going to look like on your car? What's the t-shirt you get to wear around your friends? But families aren't always asking, "Is this school actually right for my kiddo?"
Josh: And that's such an important question, because over the course of my career, I've worked with several students who were admitted to schools with incredible reputations — and they struggled once they got there, because the culture of that school wasn't right for them. They picked the school because it was high on a list, not because it was actually right for them. And Lisa, we've also worked with kids who chose schools they'd never even heard of before, and once they visited and learned more, they realized it was exactly the right fit — and they thrived.
Lisa: Right, because fit wins every time.
Josh: Every time. So let's talk about some specific factors that actually matter when we're encouraging students and families to evaluate fit — because sometimes we say the word "fit" and students still don't know what they're actually looking for beyond "have I heard of this school" or "where does it land in the latest rankings."
Lisa: To start, size is huge. There's a big difference between a school with two thousand students and a school with forty thousand. Think about class size — at a school of forty thousand, you could be in a lecture hall with four hundred and fifty people, and if you're not in the first couple of rows, you're not even going to see your professor's face. At a school of two thousand, you might have a class of twenty, where you actually get to know your professor and the people around you. I went to a very large university myself — my freshman year I had two classes with over four hundred students, and two classes with thirty and a hundred. I found my sweet spot, but you don't necessarily get that kind of range at every large university. Access to professors, campus feel, the social scene — all of that changes dramatically depending on the scale of the campus.
Josh: And to be clear, we're not advocating for one size over the other — neither is objectively better. It really depends on the student. Some students thrive at bigger universities, where there's always something going on, thousands of clubs to join, big-time college sports if that's your thing, a strong Greek life if that's what you're into. Other students want a smaller environment where they can get to know their professors by name, and a big university would swallow them whole. That's why we have all kinds of universities in the U.S. and all over the world — so students can find the environment where they'll actually do well. It goes back to that intentionality we talked about at the top of the episode.
Lisa: Location matters too. Some universities are in big cities, which opens up access to internships, professional networks, and cultural experiences — the city becomes your backyard. Other students want a college town, which is going to be smaller, more contained, a different kind of feel. Visiting is the best way to get a real sense of this. We know not every family can visit before applying, but when you can, take it all in — and parents, watch how your student reacts on campus. Sometimes they'll show you how they feel before they even realize it themselves.
Josh: Whether a student can get home easily is another big factor, especially for families that are close-knit. A school that's a two-hour drive away is very different from a school that's a two-hour flight away.
Lisa: Right — there's a real difference between driving three hours home for a Saturday night or a home-cooked meal, versus a day and a half of travel each way.
I think major matters too. Do you have an idea of what you want to study, or not? And by the way, it's okay not to know. Some schools admit by major, which means your list is going to look different depending on whether you already know what you want to study. If you have a major in mind and won't be happy without it, that shapes your list. If you don't know yet, that's completely fine too — but it still affects how you build the list.
Josh: Exactly. If you're pretty sure about a specific major, your list should include schools with strong programs in that area — not just strong schools overall. For example, a school ranked fifteenth overall that has one of the best engineering programs in the country could be a much better fit for an engineering-focused student than a school ranked fifth overall that's better known for its business program. So again, it comes back to being specific and intentional. If you have a strong inclination toward a major, make sure the schools on your list actually have strong programs in that area.
Lisa: And for students who have no idea what they want to major in, look for schools with a strong general education program — flexibility to explore different areas, and the ability to switch directions without it being a huge hurdle. Some schools make it easy to change your major a few times; at others, it's much harder to transfer between programs. Long gone are the days when you could just pick an "easier" major to get in — schools have caught on. If your intended major doesn't actually align with the rest of your application, admissions officers notice. It goes back to research and fit.
Josh: One more thing on our list today — and this is one families often leave until the very end, when it should really be at or near the beginning.
Lisa: Yeah — and that's money. The money talk.
Josh: Financial aid, scholarship opportunities, merit aid, cost of attendance versus what a family can actually afford — this is part of that fit factor too. A school that's a perfect academic and cultural fit but leaves a student and their family $150,000 in debt is not a good fit.
Lisa: No, it is not. This is also where we encourage families to look at which schools give strong merit aid, because your kiddo worked hard and should be rewarded for it. We think you should have at least one or two schools on your list where your student is highly likely to receive scholarships.
Josh: And those are usually the same schools where a student's profile is above the typical admitted range — strong merit aid candidates genuinely thrive there.
Lisa: Right, and that's another reason we push back on the word "safety." These foundation likely schools aren't a consolation prize — they're often the schools that will fight hardest for your student, offer the most aid, and give them the most opportunities to shine. The goal isn't to build a college list that looks impressive. The goal is to build a list that gives your kiddo real options.
Josh: That's so important to emphasize. Something I make sure to tell every family I work with: a balanced list is not about lowering expectations. A lot of attention goes to the reach schools, because those are the ones that grab everyone's focus, and sometimes students feel like they're "settling" if they also have to consider targets and likely schools. But the point of a balanced list isn't lowering the bar — it's building a process that's realistic, hopeful, and grounded in who the student actually is and what they actually need. It's not about having a list of the hardest schools to get into, or applying to all eight Ivies. It's about building a list that leaves a student with options, with confidence, and with room to breathe instead of carrying the weight of impossible expectations.
Lisa: That's it, Josh. That's the whole episode right there.
Josh: It can be — but we still have a few other things to get to, so let's keep it rolling.
Lisa: Okay, it's time for our hot take or hard truth. Josh, what do you got?
Josh: Applying to a school — any school — just because it's highly ranked, without ever visiting, researching its culture, or sitting down as a family to think about whether it's a genuine fit, is one of the most expensive mistakes a family can make in this process. I've known several students who spent four miserable years at highly ranked universities because they never stopped to ask whether that school was actually right for them. They saw the name, and the prestige that came with it, and didn't look any further.
Lisa: Right — and visiting and researching the culture are great ways to make sure it's a genuine fit. It also helps with essays and supplements, because you can take notes while you're there. What are students talking about? Sit in on a class if you can. What's the food like? Those details help make your writing authentically you — and they help a school see that your interest in them is real, not something you Googled forty minutes before filling out the application.
Josh: Right — and those "why us" supplemental essays feel completely different when a student genuinely knows and loves the school, versus writing about a place they don't know much about but heard they should apply to.
Lisa: And admissions offices can see through that every time. They know when a student put in real time and effort versus when they waited until the thirteenth hour.
Josh: Turns out. All right, Lisa, it's time for our Drop the Mic segment — you've got the mic this time.
Lisa: I do. Here's what I want every family to remember from this episode: the name on the diploma does not guarantee your kiddo's happiness, success, or a good experience in college. It doesn't. You know what does? Fit. Literally every time. So parents, it's time to lock this in — the goal is not to build a college list that looks impressive to your friends, your neighbors, or your coworkers. The goal is to help your kiddo build a balanced list. A balanced list isn't about lowering expectations — it's about creating a process that's realistic, hopeful, and grounded in who your student actually is and what they actually need. Build the list for them, and no one else.
Josh: Amen. And just to reiterate what Lisa said — this week's homework: before you do anything else in this process, sit down together. Students, sit down with your parents. Parents, sit down with your student. Ask yourselves: what does the student actually want their college experience to feel like? Not the name of the school, not where it ranks — what do they want it to feel like? Once you can answer that question, that's when you can start building your list.
Lisa: That's it, Josh. That's the work. So do it.
Josh: Exactly. That'll wrap things up for us this week. Next week, we're getting into one of the things that makes families more anxious than almost anything else in this process.
Lisa: The college essay.
Josh: We're going to break down exactly how to write an essay that actually sounds like the student — not like a parent, not like a college counselor, and definitely not like ChatGPT.
Lisa: Josh, I think that's what we're seeing the most right now. And remember, going back to episode one — you are not behind in this process. But to help with that, let's start checking things off the list. Right after building your college list, the essay is next. That's what you really need to start working on — brainstorming, getting the wheels turning. Because it's the one essay only your kiddo could write. It needs to sound like them, not like anyone else.
Josh: That's right.
Lisa: So tune in — we're going to show you exactly how to do it.
Lisa: Remember, we're Decision Drop. We're making your college journey collaborative, simple, but most importantly, yours. If you want to learn more about our services, or have Josh and I guide you through the process personally, head over to decisiondrop.com and check us out.
Josh: Thanks for dropping in. We'll see y'all next week.
