Surviving the Holidays as a High School Senior: How to Handle College Questions From Family

Somewhere between the mashed potatoes and the pie, Aunt Linda is going to lean across the table and ask where you're applying. She means well. She also has opinions about every school you name.

Every November we hear from seniors who are more nervous about Thanksgiving dinner than about their essays. The timing this year makes it worse, since the December holidays land right around when early decisions come out. So let's talk about what to say.

Talk With Your Parents Before the First Holiday Gathering

Take ten minutes before anyone gets in the car and decide together what's okay to share. Some students don't care if the whole list goes around the table. If you'd rather keep it to "a few schools in the Northeast," tell your parents now, so your dad doesn't announce your reach school while he's passing the rolls.

Test scores and financial aid can stay in the family. Your mom can handle that one with "Oh, we're keeping that between us," and then ask who wants more pie.

How to Answer "So, Where Are You Applying?"

Come up with one answer and say it the same way every time. “We've got a mix of mid-sized schools, mostly in cities, and there are a couple we're pretty excited about” should do the trick. Then bring up something you like talking about, like the robotics lab you saw on a tour. Your relatives want something to chat with you about, and the robots should give Grandpa plenty to ask.

If someone follows up with “Okay, but what's your first choice?” try “We're keeping the list private for now, but that robotics lab was pretty cool.” You can also give them something real to talk about without naming a favorite. Maybe one campus surprised you because students could get involved in research early. Maybe a tour made you realize you actually want a smaller school. Those details tell the people who love you something about what you're looking for.

What to Say When Relatives Give Outdated College Advice

A lot of grown-ups applied to college back when you sent five applications and everybody took the SAT. Now plenty of students apply to ten or more, and lots of schools are test optional. (If anyone's curious, we explain how test optional works.)

So when Uncle Rob tells you his school is a sure thing, try "It's gotten a lot more competitive since you went," and then ask him what he loved about it. Twenty minutes later you'll know all about his freshman roommate, Gary.

How to Handle "Did You Get In Yet?"

Many Early Decision and Early Action results come out in December, though some Early Action schools release decisions in January or February. Regular Decision answers often show up in March, and some arrive in early April. If someone at the table heard from a college last week, that tells you when that student's decision came out. Your own applicant portal is the place to check for your school's timing.

You can just say, “We'll have some news in December, and we'll share it when we're ready.” If you've already heard and want to keep it private, “We're keeping decisions within the family for now” works, too. Grandma might ask three times before dessert, so get comfortable with that line.

Where to Open Your Early Decision or Early Action Result

Colleges post decisions at a set time, and some of those days fall right in the middle of holiday travel. Figure out ahead of time where you'll be when you log in. Your bedroom, with a parent close by, is a good spot. If there's a party that night, wait until you get home.

Give yourself a day or two before you tell the extended family, whatever the news is. And if the decision page is confusing, our post on reading your applicant portal without panicking can help.

What to Say After a Deferral or Denial

SSome of you will walk into a family dinner a few days after a deferral or a denial. You decide how much to say. After a denial, “That early school didn't work out, and we're focusing on the rest of the list” is plenty. If you're still disappointed and would rather skip the follow-up questions, “We're taking a little time before we talk about it” works, too.

If you got deferred, try “We're still waiting on a final decision. They'll review the application again later in the cycle.” Once you have some quiet time, go back to the letter. Some colleges ask you to confirm that you want to stay under consideration. Others give you a specific place to submit an update or ask for midyear grades through your school counselor. Follow the directions for that college and keep moving on any January applications you still plan to submit.

We talked through what to do next on Episode 11 of Drop In. Our post on accepted, denied, and deferred decisions lays out the steps.

How to Handle Comparisons With Cousins and Friends

There's usually a cousin in the same grade, and somebody at the table will start comparing. Be happy for your cousin when good news comes. Your list was built around you and what you want out of college (more on that in our post about building a college list). If the comparing keeps going, give your mom a look and let her change the subject.

December on Instagram is a lot. Wait to post your own news until the people closest to you have heard it, and go ahead and mute a few accounts until break is over.

Making Time for January 1 Applications Over Winter Break

Lots of Regular Decision apps are due January 1, right in the middle of everything. Put a couple of mornings on the family calendar and treat them like a work shift. “We've got college applications due January 1, so we're keeping tomorrow morning free” gives everyone a chance to plan around it.

Before school closes, check each college's actual deadline and make a short list of what's left. Separate the work you can do over break, like revising a supplement, from anything you need someone else to do, like sending a transcript or recommendation. If you're waiting on an early result, go ahead and draft the January supplements for the schools you'd still want to apply to after a deferral or denial. That's a much easier assignment before decision day than the morning after it.

Use your last work block to preview each application, check for any separate writing supplement, and confirm that both pieces show as submitted. If a supplement has you stuck, our post on writing supplemental essays might help.

A Note for Parents

You'll get questions too, usually right after your kid leaves the room. Stick to what the two of you agreed on. Something like “We're proud of how hard she's worked, and we'll know more in the spring” is plenty.

The moment to step in is often the second or third question. Your kiddo may be perfectly happy to talk about a campus visit and still need you to jump in when dinner turns into a conversation about scores, money, or why they didn't apply to somebody's alma mater. You can say, “We're keeping that part to ourselves. Hey, how did your kitchen renovation turn out?” Then let your student get back to their pie.

If a decision comes out during the holidays, ask your student what they want from you before they open it. Some want a hug. Some want help figuring out what the letter says. Some want twenty minutes alone with the dog. If they get disappointing news, you can take care of the relatives' questions while your kid takes a breath. We got into this on Episode 13 of Drop In, and our post on how much parents should help goes further.

The Bottom Line

  • Talk with your parents first about what's okay to share, including scores, financial aid, and decisions.

  • Have one go-to answer for “Where are you applying?”

  • Pick a quiet spot to open an early decision, and decide when you're ready to tell relatives.

  • Block off a couple of mornings over break for January 1 apps, and check what you need from your school before it closes.

If you have questions, want to learn more, or want Josh and Lisa to help with your college process? Schedule a call today, and we have you covered!

Next
Next

What's Actually Worth Doing This Summer? A Summer Planning Guide for High School Students and Parents