Episode Description:
In Episode 23 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh are talking mostly to parents about something that can get very loud during college admissions season: everybody else's opinions.
Parent group chats can be incredibly helpful. They can answer questions about applicant portals, deadlines, emails, and things other families have already figured out. But they can also make you question your kiddo's entire college list in about 15 minutes.
Then the holidays arrive.
Where are they applying? Did they submit scores? Have they gotten in anywhere yet? What was their SAT? What are you paying? Nothing says holiday cheer quite like an unsolicited admissions interrogation.
Lisa and Josh talk about how parents can use group chats without letting comparison take over, how families can set boundaries before holiday gatherings, and why another student's acceptance, denial, GPA, or test score does not predict what will happen to your own kiddo.
If your senior is already bracing for the family questions, our companion guide, Surviving the Holidays as a High School Senior: How to Handle College Questions From Family, gives students and parents practical language for the holiday table, early decisions, deferrals, January applications, and all those well-meaning relatives with opinions.
When the Parent Group Chat Stops Being Helpful
The problem is not that parents talk to other parents. The problem starts when somebody else's student begins changing the way you talk to your own.
One student got denied with a higher GPA. Another submitted test scores. Someone applied early to a school your kiddo did not even consider. Suddenly you're wondering whether your student should add another college, change a testing decision, or rethink a list they were perfectly comfortable with yesterday.
But you do not know the whole story.
Two students can have exactly the same GPA and very different transcripts. They can apply to the same university but to completely different majors or colleges within it. You do not know every class, essay, recommendation, activity, family circumstance, institutional priority, or piece of context behind somebody else's result.
A parent group chat can tell you what happened to another student. It cannot predict what will happen to yours. And if opening that chat leaves you more anxious than when you started, Lisa has a very sophisticated admissions strategy for you:
Mute it.
Use other parents as a source of information, not as voters in your student's college process.
Come Back to Your Kiddo
If comparison starts creeping into the house, go back to the person whose opinion actually matters. Which schools can your student genuinely picture themselves attending? What excites them? What kind of environment feels right? What do they want from college?
Then comes the important part: ask the question and listen to the answer.
Lisa likes to ask students, “Do you need my opinion, or do you need my support?” Sometimes your kiddo does not need another strategy session. They need you to remember that the college process belongs to them. You have a pretty incredible human sitting right in front of you. Do not let somebody else's student make you forget that.
Surviving the Holiday Table
Before heading to the first family gathering, spend ten minutes deciding together what is and is not okay to share.
Some students are perfectly happy telling everyone their entire college list. Others would rather say they are looking at “a few schools in the Northeast” and leave it there. Both are fine. Test scores, financial aid, scholarship amounts, and admission decisions can also stay private. Your family gets to decide where that line is.
And when Aunt Linda asks again?
“We'll share when we're ready.”
Then pass the pie.
If your family is still working through applications, deadlines, or last-minute strategy, our college counseling services for high school seniors explain how Lisa and Josh can help with applications, essays, deferrals, decisions, and everything in between.
Another Student's Decision Is Not a Prediction
One of the most damaging things a parent can say is:
“So-and-so got denied, and their stats are better than yours.”
Your student probably does not hear that as sophisticated admissions analysis. They hear, “Someone better than me couldn't get in, so why would I?” That is not how admissions works.
Colleges are not simply putting every applicant in GPA order and admitting from the top down. They are building a class, and what they need can change from year to year. Another student's result is one student's result. That is it.
If your family is navigating an acceptance, denial, or deferral, Episode 11 of Drop In goes deeper into what those decisions mean and what students can do next.
College Decisions During the Holidays
Early Decision and Early Action results often arrive right in the middle of holiday travel, parties, and family gatherings.
Talk about the moment before it happens. Does your kiddo want you beside them when they open the decision? Do they want to open it alone? Do they want anyone filming? If the answer is disappointing, do they want a hug immediately, 20 minutes alone, or maybe just the dog?
Students get a vote here too.
A denial or deferral does not require an immediate press conference for the extended family. Your student can take some time before deciding whether they want to tell anyone at all.
“We're still waiting on a final decision.”
“That early school didn't work out, so we're focusing on the rest of the list.”
“We'll share when we're ready.”
All perfectly acceptable answers.
Do Not Turn Winter Break Into Application Camp
For seniors with January Regular Decision deadlines, some work may still need to happen over the holidays.
Lisa and Josh suggest scheduling a few dedicated work blocks, almost like shifts. Work on applications for a morning, finish what needs to be done, and then stop.
Winter break does not need to become Boot Camp 2.0.
Before school closes, students should also make sure they know whether they still need anything from their counselor, including transcripts or recommendation materials. And if January supplements are still outstanding, finishing them before an Early Decision result arrives is much easier than trying to write them the morning after disappointing news.
And Yes, You Can Mute Social Media Too
You can be genuinely happy for somebody else and still decide that you do not need to watch 19 acceptance-reaction videos over dinner.
Both things can be true.
The same rule applies to social media that applies to the parent group chat: if it is making the process harder, step away.
The Relationship Matters More Than the Process
Lisa's final reminder is for parents:
The college process is temporary.
Your relationship with your kiddo is not.
Your job is not to make your student's process look like somebody else's. It is to know your kid. Know what lights them up. Know when they need encouragement. Know when they need help, and know when they need everyone to stop talking about college and watch a movie.
Josh's rule is even simpler:
Nobody in the parent group chat gets a vote.
Neither does Aunt Linda. Information can be useful. Advice can be useful. Other families' experiences can teach you something. But when it is time to make actual decisions, come back to your student. If you want someone in your corner who knows your student, not somebody else's, connect with Lisa and Josh at Decision Drop.
In This Episode
How parent group chats can fuel college admissions comparison
Why another student's result does not predict your kiddo's chances
When to mute the group chat and step away
How to handle college questions from relatives
What families should decide before holiday gatherings
How to handle Early Decision and Early Action results
How to protect winter break during Regular Decision season
Why your relationship with your kiddo matters more than the admissions noise
🎙️ Also available on: Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeart
Top Questions Answered in this Episode
Can parent group chats be helpful during college admissions?
Yes. Parent group chats can be useful for practical questions about deadlines, applicant portals, emails, school procedures, and other families' experiences. They become less helpful when parents start using another student's GPA, test scores, college list, or admission result to judge their own student's chances.
Does another student's college decision predict my student's chances?
No. Two students with similar GPAs or test scores can have very different transcripts, essays, recommendations, activities, intended majors, school contexts, and application circumstances. Colleges also have institutional priorities that can change from year to year. Another student's result tells you what happened to that student, not what will happen to yours.
What should parents do if college comparison starts causing stress?
Step away from the source of the comparison. That may mean muting a parent group chat, taking a break from social media, or simply stopping conversations that are creating more anxiety than useful information. Then come back to your own student, their college list, their goals, and what matters to them.
How should families handle college questions from relatives during the holidays?
Talk before the gathering about what the student is comfortable sharing. Some students are happy to discuss their entire list, while others want to keep schools, scores, financial aid, scholarships, or decisions private. Families can prepare a simple answer such as, “We're keeping that part within the family,” or “We'll share when we're ready.”
Should parents film their student's college decision reaction?
Only if the student wants that. Families should talk beforehand about where the student wants to open the decision, who they want present, whether they want a camera, and what kind of support they may want afterward. The student should have a meaningful say in how that moment happens.
What should a student say after a college deferral or denial?
Students do not owe extended family a detailed explanation. After a denial, something as simple as, “That early school didn't work out, so I'm focusing on the rest of my list,” is enough. After a deferral, a student can say, “We're still waiting on a final decision. They'll review my application again later.”
How should seniors manage January applications over winter break?
Schedule a few dedicated application work blocks rather than turning the entire break into college-application time. Before school closes, check deadlines and make sure counselors have everything they need to send. If January supplements are unfinished, completing them before Early Decision results arrive can also reduce pressure.
How can parents support their senior during college decision season?
Know when your student needs advice and when they simply need support. Ask what they want, listen to the answer, protect their privacy when needed, and avoid making their process look like someone else's. The college process is temporary, but the parent-student relationship lasts much longer.
Chapters
00:00 – Parent Group Chats, Holiday Questions & College Admissions Stress
02:52 – When Parent Group Chats Stop Being Helpful
04:49 – Why Comparison Changes How You Talk to Your Kiddo
05:44 – Why Another Student’s Results Do NOT Predict Yours
07:57 – What to Do When the Group Chat Starts Taking Over
09:17 – How to Handle College Questions at the Holiday Table
13:32 – Family Comparison, Cousins & Protecting Your Kiddo
14:40 – Opening College Decisions During the Holidays
16:57 – Regular Decision Applications Over Winter Break
18:41 – Social Media, Acceptance Posts & Knowing When to Mute
19:12 – Lightning Round: Holiday Edition
21:22 – Hot Take: Other Students’ Results Are Not Data Points for Yours
23:14 – Drop the Mic: Your Relationship With Your Kiddo Comes First
25:33 – Next Week: College in Rome with Temple University Rome
Read the full Episode 23 transcript
Josh (00:01.588)
Every week we drop the noise and drop some knowledge.
Lisa (00:03.405)
Drop the stress. Welcome to the Drop In, the College Admissions podcast by Decision Drop. If you want to learn more about our services or have Josh and I
Lisa (00:18.071)
Sorry. Here we go. It's because my picture left and yours jumped in my face and I can only see you and not me. Welcome to the Drop In, the College Admissions podcast by Decision Drop. If you want to learn more about our services or have Josh and I guide your family through this process personally, head over to decisiondrop.com and check us out. And remember, please like and subscribe.
Josh (00:51.248)
I'm Josh.
Lisa (00:52.437)
I'm Lisa. Let's go.
Josh (00:56.074)
Alrighty, Lisa, episode 23. And for this one, we have a little bit of change of plans this week.
Lisa (01:04.31)
We do. I know we were very excited, y'all, because we were supposed to have an amazing conversation with Dean Zakina today, but due to some scheduling conflicts, that's gonna be postponed to next week. So we just have to wait one more week.
Josh (01:17.39)
Exactly. And this opening left us with the question, what do we want to talk about this week?
Lisa (01:24.163)
Sure. So then you know what? We looked at our calendars and Josh and I were like, wait, the holidays are basically here. So honestly, this might have worked out perfectly because this is an episode we wanted to get to before everybody starts traveling and families start getting together, and then you got that group text that's blowing up, and then before you sit down and have dinner with all your relatives.
Josh (02:02.816)
Exactly. So those relatives have questions and they have opinions.
Lisa (02:07.639)
So many opinions.
Josh (02:09.804)
Yeah. So today is going to be a little different. Most weeks we spend a lot of time talking directly to students. Today, parents, this one is going to be mostly for you. And I really need you to hear me on this one.
Lisa (02:24.289)
We mean that, y'all. We are talking about the parent group chat, right? So this is where we're gonna start because those chats can actually be incredibly helpful sometimes. And they can also get in your head super fast.
Josh (02:42.026)
Yeah. And then we're moving from the group chat to the holiday table because the questions about college are coming.
Lisa (02:48.597)
Right, so where are they applying? Did they submit test scores? Did they get in anywhere yet? What was their SAT? What are you paying? Right?
Josh (02:58.19)
Exactly. Nothing says holiday cheer quite like unsolicited admissions interrogations.
Lisa (03:05.065)
Exactly. So let's talk about how to use the group chat without, big keyword, without letting it ruin your kiddo's college process, and how to handle Aunt Linda at dinner and how to protect a little bit of peace during the season that is already busy enough.
Josh (03:25.024)
Yeah, good old Aunt Linda. You know, there's an old saying: if you don't know who Aunt Linda in your family is, chances are that means you are Aunt Linda. So let's get into it. Alrighty. So Lisa, those parent group chats we talked about, they can be super helpful.
Lisa (03:33.195)
You are Aunt Linda. True. Let's get into it.
Lisa (03:45.389)
Absolutely. You can ask questions. You can hear what other families are doing. You can actually learn from someone who's already dealt with something that you're just now trying to figure out.
Josh (03:56.918)
Yeah, exactly. So, you know, questions like, did anybody else get this email? When do the applicant portals open? Is everyone seeing the same thing? If you can ask those questions to get general answers to them, those are helpful. Those are useful.
Lisa (04:10.284)
Right. Also, questions like, did your kids submit test scores? How many APs are they taking? Where did they apply early? Listen, you are comparing everything to your kiddo. But listen, y'all, that is their kiddo, not your kiddo, right? It's their college list, not your college list. Those are their results for their kids and their kids' chances.
Josh (04:35.523)
Right.
Lisa (04:40.374)
Not your kids' chances. I think that's the most important thing that Josh and I are trying to make sure that we get across in this episode. Parents, this is where you truly need to be careful because that comparison does not just affect how you feel about the college process.
Josh (04:58.028)
Yeah, and speaking of comparisons, some unhelpful questions that can lead you down rabbit holes can be things like, what was your student's GPA? How many activities did they have? Did they get accepted already? Did they get denied? Why? Did they get deferred? These kinds of questions lead to unhelpful comparisons.
Lisa (05:04.569)
Mm-hmm.
Lisa (05:19.222)
Right. And you're just comparing, y'all. It can truly change how the process works. So think about it this way. When you have that comparison, that is the part that we really don't want families to lose. Keep the context. We're gonna circle back to the word context again because suddenly your perfectly happy kiddo is sitting there, and then you're asking, well, why didn't you apply there? Or should we submit those test scores? I know you weren't going to submit them, or I know you talked to your counselor and they decided that you shouldn't. But then I talked to Sarah and we think you should submit them, right? And none of those questions actually existed until you, parents, opened that group chat.
Josh (06:06.986)
Right. And that group chat can change how you start talking to your own kid.
Lisa (06:11.748)
True. So this information, I think, is the most important thing. Again, context. I know we cannot say that enough. Because here's the thing: you do not know the whole story. You actually have no idea what chapter of the book you walked in on for that particular kiddo. You have no context to what they are talking about.
Josh (06:41.39)
Mm-hmm.
Josh (06:46.178)
Right. And the most important thing is that you don't want to transfer the anxiety that you have from these unhelpful questions in the group chat to your student who, as Lisa mentioned, might be perfectly fine and going through the process each step of the way and checking off the boxes.
Lisa (07:02.818)
Right, exactly. You do not know what you don't know. Every class that the student took, you don't know what they took. You don't know every part of their application. You don't know what their recommendations said. You don't know what's happening in their family. And you also do not know what that particular college needed from that particular class in that particular year.
Josh (07:27.874)
Okay, I'm a little lost here. I think we deviated from the script.
Lisa (07:35.645)
Where are you at?
Josh (07:37.428)
Where are you? Are you in segment three?
Lisa (07:39.726)
Uh-huh.
Josh (07:44.406)
Was that the first line where you talk about the book in the middle of the chapter? Because we didn't say anything about the...
Lisa (07:47.69)
Uh-huh. I did. I did. I talked about you walked in the middle of the book, the chapter of the kid. That's okay. So how about can you say pause and then say two students that have exactly the same GPA? Do you see that?
Josh (07:53.878)
I totally missed that. Okay.
Josh (08:05.77)
Yeah, I was like several lines behind. Okay, got it. Okay.
Lisa (08:09.15)
Sorry. I think it still makes sense though, what we were saying. Okay. But yeah, no. I talked about the book and then you didn't say this, so I was like, maybe you just aren't saying it, which I love. I love it. No.
Josh (08:12.854)
It does, yeah. Okay.
Josh (08:21.846)
I totally missed it. Okay, here we go. So two students can have exactly the same GPA but have very different transcripts. They can apply to the same university and be applying to completely different colleges or majors within that university, which are very different admissions processes.
Lisa (08:42.722)
Right. But then all you see in that group chat, y'all, is accepted, denied, deferred. And then suddenly you start changing your kiddo's college list or college plan based on what somebody else's results are. And then you start to think, well, maybe we should add that school or maybe we should do what they're doing.
Josh (09:05.686)
Yeah. Or it's, I don't think you should apply there anymore. And then here's the one, Lisa, that I really want parents to stop saying: well, so-and-so got denied and their stats are better than yours. Please, parents, please don't say this to your student.
Lisa (09:16.78)
Mm-hmm.
Lisa (09:23.428)
Right. Because you know what? Your kid unfortunately hears, somebody better than me got denied, so why would I get in? And that is not even how any of this works, y'all. If you have heard any of our episodes leading up to now, we keep talking about this. This is the Wild West. That is not how this works.
Josh (09:54.743)
Exactly. Because your student will not hear that as useful admissions analysis, right? Every application is different and colleges are not simply lining students up by GPA and test score and admitting them from the top down. They're building a class. It's something that we've talked about on multiple episodes before. They're building a class, which means that sometimes they'll make decisions that don't make sense to you, but to the college and their institutional priorities, it makes total sense.
Lisa (10:21.58)
Right. And what a school needs can change every single year. We have talked about this before. Maybe they need more students in a certain program. Or maybe they need more students from a certain particular region of the country. Maybe they need something in a class that has absolutely nothing to do with your kiddo.
Josh (10:41.248)
Yes. So that group chat can tell you what happened to another student, but it cannot predict what is going to happen to your student.
Lisa (10:49.922)
Right. So yes, ask the questions, learn from other parents, that's great, but listen to their experiences. Just do not let their experiences start steering your kiddo's process.
Josh (11:06.708)
Exactly, because once you open that Pandora's box, everybody in that group chat suddenly gets a little vote in your student's college list.
Lisa (11:14.846)
And they absolutely do not get a vote, y'all. They don't.
Josh (11:19.254)
Right. So parents, what do you do when you feel yourself getting sucked into that group chat?
Lisa (11:24.844)
Mute it. Seriously. Mute the group chat. Put the phone down and go talk to the person whose opinion actually matters, y'all.
Josh (11:36.472)
Yeah. And that would be your student.
Lisa (11:38.806)
Your kiddo. Find the school that fits them. Build that list that makes sense for them. Talk about what they are excited about and let them enjoy the process and let that process belong to them. I know, crazy idea.
Josh (11:57.111)
Yeah. It is pretty radical. And parents, if you don't know where to start, you can start by asking something very simple. Which of these schools can you actually picture yourself at? And then you can follow it up with, what makes you say that?
Lisa (12:11.522)
Right. And this next part is really important, y'all. Listen. Ask them the question and then listen to their answer. Do not immediately tell them why they are wrong. I like to actually start out conversations, and Josh knows this, especially with our students, and say, listen, do you need my opinion or do you need my support? This is the part, parents, where your kiddos need your support. So ask them the questions.
Josh (12:39.011)
Mm.
Lisa (12:41.164)
And listen to their answers, right? Put on your listening ears. Because you have a pretty incredible human sitting right in front of you. So do not let anyone else's student make you forget that.
Josh (12:55.724)
That's great advice, Lisa. All right, parents. So you muted the chat, you're feeling good, and then the holidays arrive.
Lisa (12:59.95)
Mm-hmm.
Lisa (13:05.044)
And then the holidays arrive, right? So we are glad that we were talking about this because we are in holiday season, y'all. And it is about to fast forward in the months of November, December, and January. So somewhere between that mac and cheese and dessert, Aunt Linda leans across the table and looks at you or your kiddo and says, so where are y'all applying?
Josh (13:28.95)
And Aunt Linda, bless her heart, she does mean well.
Lisa (13:34.54)
She does, but she also probably has a story about every single college that you named.
Josh (13:43.138)
But unfortunately, that's from Ronald Reagan's second term, towards the end of it.
Lisa (13:46.532)
Right. So here is what we want families to do before you walk into that first holiday gathering. Spend 10 minutes in the car or before you leave the house and decide as a family what is and is not okay to share.
Josh (14:08.534)
Exactly. And you want to have that conversation because you want it to be kid-specific, right? Every student is different. Some students genuinely don't care if everybody knows their entire college list.
Lisa (14:18.69)
Right. Or then you have other kiddos who would rather tell grandma that they are applying to some school in the Northeast and then just leave it at that. Both are fine. But parents, you need to know which kid you have before Dad announces to the entire family table what your reach school was while everyone's trying to pass around the rolls. Come on.
Josh (14:44.6)
Exactly. Passing rolls and the butter is important. And there are some things that can simply stay private. Test scores, financial aid, scholarship numbers.
Lisa (14:46.862)
Yeah.
Lisa (14:57.422)
Sure. How about if someone asks you that, just say, you know what, we're keeping that part between us. Who wants more pie? Right? Done and done.
Josh (15:07.872)
Hey, redirecting with Nana's sweet potato pie is very effective.
Lisa (15:12.426)
Always. So students, it also helps to have one answer ready. Something easy. Like, I have a mix of mid-sized schools, mostly in cities, and there's a couple that I'm excited about. And then you know what? Just stop. You do not owe anyone a Google Slide presentation. Josh and I are releasing you of that. It can be a quick, short answer, and then go about your day.
Josh (15:37.89)
Mm-hmm.
Josh (15:42.987)
Yeah, and that's so important too, for students to not feel obligated to give this long-winded answer. And students, if relatives genuinely want to connect, give them something fun. Tell them about the robotics lab you saw. You can tell them about the campus that had the incredible student center. You can tell them about the really cool offerings in the dining hall that you saw.
Lisa (16:06.178)
Right, because let's be honest, y'all. They're really probably not trying to interrogate you. They really just want to talk to you. So give them something easy to talk about.
Josh (16:18.112)
Yes. Now students, we also have to address outdated advice.
Lisa (16:24.004)
Mmm, yes, Josh. Outdated advice. Because plenty of adults applied to college in a very, very different admissions world, right? You had two applications and everybody took the SAT, no Common App, no portal, no 15 supplements that you have to write.
Josh (16:45.93)
Exactly. So when Uncle Rob, who went to school during Clinton's first term, says something like, man, that school's a sure thing, you don't have to get into a debate with him.
Lisa (16:56.642)
Right. Try, you know, we're hearing that admissions has gotten a lot more competitive since you went. What did you love about it when you were there? And you know what, kiddo? Congratulations. You have now redirected Uncle Rob to telling you about college for the next 20 minutes.
Josh (17:15.574)
Yeah, nobody wants to hear about Uncle Rob's freshman roommate.
Lisa (17:18.88)
You know, Gary. There's always a Gary. So we have a Rob, a Gary, a Linda, right?
Josh (17:23.052)
That's right. And like I said about Aunt Linda, if you don't know Gary, then you probably were Gary.
Lisa (17:30.048)
You probably were Gary. Man, I'm loving this episode. Don't be a Gary. Could that be a sticker? Don't be a Gary?
Josh (17:32.354)
Don't be a Gary.
Josh (17:36.078)
It could, but out of context, that seems weird. Anyway.
Lisa (17:41.484)
That's true, but by the way, I have not talked about our merch in a couple of podcasts, so I'm feeling like it's okay for me to start that up again, right? Don't be a Gary. Also, I'm super hungry right now. I think it's because of all the food that we're talking about. All right. So kiddos and parents, listen. There is that holiday table comparison, right? The one that we haven't talked about yet, where it's, "Well, your cousin..."
Josh (17:50.369)
Okay.
Josh (17:56.086)
Yes.
Lisa (18:10.498)
"...has already got into three schools."
Josh (18:13.366)
Exactly. And if this happens, guys, the same rule as the group chat. Hit them with, we're really excited for them. Our schools are on a different timeline. Done.
Lisa (18:22.904)
Done. It's perfect. Because that is actually true. Some colleges answer super quickly. Some kiddos will not hear until March. There is absolutely no prize for being the first cousin with the acceptance letter. So remember that.
Josh (18:38.944)
Yeah. And parents, this is also the part where you might need to step in.
Lisa (18:43.682)
Yes. If you see your kiddo getting uncomfortable, save them. Maybe you jump in and say, you know what, we're keeping that part private. And then immediately, hey, how'd your kitchen renovation go? Or how'd it turn out? Redirect. Easy to do.
Josh (19:01.078)
Yeah. That Uno reverse right there will make your kid love you forever.
Lisa (19:06.058)
And let them get back to their dessert of choice because now you are handling the tough questions that they don't want to handle.
Josh (19:15.2)
Exactly. And there is another reason that this season, see what I did there? Reason, season. Can get complicated. A lot of early decisions come out in December. Some Early Action as well. So that's right in the middle of travel, family gatherings, and the endless holiday parties.
Lisa (19:20.89)
I did. I love that. Yeah.
Lisa (19:34.884)
So we want families to think about this before decisions land, right? Where does your kiddo want to be when they open up that decision? Who do they want to be there? Do they want someone filming them? Because that is not something that you as a family need to figure out with your finger or your student's finger hovering over that "view update." So it's great to talk about that before you get to this point.
Josh (20:01.206)
Exactly. And students, remember, you get to decide. Maybe you want your parents beside you. Maybe you want to be alone to open the decision and then call someone. Maybe you absolutely don't want a camera in your face.
Lisa (20:14.296)
Right. And parents, ask, right? Do you mind me sitting with you? Or do you want a hug if it's bad news? Do you want 20 minutes alone? Some kiddos need you immediately. But then some kiddos actually might need their dog immediately. And again, I know I project a lot on these podcasts and I'm projecting because I also just want all the dogs. So I would actually want the dog immediately. But yeah, that's just me.
Josh (20:41.836)
You know, that's important. Doggies are important. And students, whatever the result is, you don't have to announce it to the extended family immediately or even at all.
Lisa (20:52.278)
No. Y'all, just give yourself five minutes, especially if it's a deferral or a denial, because you do not owe anyone an explanation. That early school might not have worked out. So now you're gonna focus on the rest of your list. That's enough. That's all you actually need to say, if you even need to say anything at all. Remember, it's your choice.
Josh (21:13.25)
Right. And exactly. And if you're deferred and if you do choose to engage with family if they ask, you could say something like, we're still waiting on a final decision. They'll review the application again at a later date. Then when things are quiet, go back and read what the college actually wants you to do next.
Lisa (21:20.132)
Mm-hmm.
Lisa (21:24.772)
Mm-hmm.
Lisa (21:33.24)
Right. And then when somebody asks, did you get in yet, for the third time before dessert? You know what? We'll share the news when we're ready. See? Beautiful, simple, easy, done and done.
Josh (21:47.831)
Right. And on another practical note, for those kids who might be less Early Decision, less Early Action, but more Regular Decision, remember those applications are due around January 1.
Lisa (21:59.684)
Which means holiday break is not all holiday movies and pajamas for seniors. So that's important to remember.
Josh (22:08.342)
Exactly. But students, our advice for you, to make sure that you do enjoy some part of your break, because everyone needs it, especially at this time of year, put a couple of work blocks on the family calendar. Schedule your time. A morning here, a morning there. Treat these applications that you're still filling out for Regular Decision like work shifts. You got your morning shift, you got an afternoon shift, then stop.
Lisa (22:15.928)
Mm-hmm.
Lisa (22:30.41)
Yes. Sorry. I got so excited, Josh, because you were talking about the calendar and I can just think of all the color codes. And it's perfect. Because parents, don't turn every day of break into an application camp, right? Y'all have already had a boot camp. Let's not make it Boot Camp 2.0. Get the work done and then you get to have a break. So parents, let your kiddos get the work done and then let them...
Josh (22:38.338)
Yeah.
Lisa (22:59.928)
Have a break.
Josh (23:02.398)
Great advice. And students, before school closes, this is important. Make sure you know whether you need anything else from your counselors. Transcripts to be sent, recommendations, et cetera, that they might need to send before everyone leaves for the holidays.
Lisa (23:06.901)
Mm.
Lisa (23:19.604)
One thousand percent, Josh. Because if you're waiting on that early decision but you still have January applications, write the supplements now. Please. It is much easier to finish them while you are calm than in the morning after a disappointing decision. So remember that too.
Josh (23:39.424)
Yeah. All right. Last one we gotta talk about: social media.
Lisa (23:46.292)
Social media. You know, mute some accounts, y'all. We are giving you permission. You can be genuinely happy for your friends and decide that you do not need to watch 19 acceptance reaction videos while you're eating dinner. Both things can be true at the same time. So remember that.
Josh (24:12.961)
Amen.
Lisa (24:14.05)
Right. Okay, Josh. Listen, we are gonna try this again because I know we've been working on this, or more I have been, because you're great at this lightning round. I am not great at these lightning rounds. I just start getting nervous, right? And I can't think of what I want to say, which is kind of unlike me, let's be honest. All right, so how about we try lightning round holiday edition?
Josh (24:25.944)
Well, we've been practicing, you know.
Josh (24:43.98)
All right, Lisa. Remember, quick questions, straight answers. Go.
Lisa (24:48.484)
Great answers. Okay, I'll start. All right, Josh. Group chat: mute or leave?
Josh (24:55.424)
Easy. Mute. You can always come back to it in the spring. All right, Lisa, best way to change the subject at the table?
Lisa (24:58.371)
Hmm, very true.
Lisa (25:02.844)
Ooh! Who wants more pie? Works every time. Okay, I'm getting this. All right, Josh. Share the whole college list with your relatives, yes or no?
Josh (25:17.248)
Only if your kiddo says yes.
Lisa (25:19.844)
Okay. Very true.
Josh (25:20.94)
All right, Lisa. Film the decision reaction?
Lisa (25:25.102)
Student's call. Remember, parents, you need to ask them first. So maybe a yes or maybe a no. That was okay, right? That was kind of quick. Okay. All right. So Josh, one sentence parents should retire this season. Go.
Josh (25:34.338)
Yep. Brilliant.
Josh (25:42.284)
"So-and-so got in..." and stop right there. Just stop it.
Lisa (25:45.494)
Mm. Yep. Nope. Perfect.
Josh (25:49.642)
All right, Lisa. One question parents should ask instead.
Lisa (25:54.545)
Which school can you picture yourself at?
Josh (25:58.723)
Pretty good. Short and to the point.
Lisa (25:59.694)
Okay. Thank you. All right. So last one, Josh. Let's finish with a bang. Finish this sentence: the best thing a parent can do this holiday season is...
Josh (26:13.122)
Be the calmest person at the dining room table.
Lisa (26:18.072)
Be the calmest person. Oof. I like that. Yes, yes, and yes.
So not bad. I think we're getting, by we, more me, getting the hang of it. Josh, you're doing pretty well. I like it. Okay. So y'all, it is that time towards the end of our segment that we love. It is Hot Take, Hard Truth. So Josh, please do the honors and go first.
Josh (26:44.022)
Okay, so here's mine. All right, students and parents. Somebody else's result tells you almost nothing about your student's chances. Not your acceptance. So I'm gonna do that over.
Josh (27:01.154)
Alrighty. My hard truth: somebody else's result tells you almost nothing about your student's chances. Not their acceptance, not their denial, not their deferral.
Families want to use those results as data points. I know a kid with a 1480 who got denied, so... But you don't have the kid's application. You don't know what program they applied to. You don't know what their school offered. You don't know their essays or recommendation letters or even the context of their application, or even what the particular college they applied to is trying to build that year in terms of a class.
So stop treating another student's result like a prediction for yours. It's not.
Lisa (27:42.456)
Right, 100%. Their story is their story. Yes, Josh. Ooh, that's a hard one to follow.
Okay, so my hot take for this week: the parent group chat can create way more stress than actual college applications. And I say that as somebody who thinks those group chats can be incredibly helpful.
Sometimes. Remember, sometimes is the keyword here.
But parents, if you open that chat feeling perfectly fine and 15 minutes later you are questioning your kiddo's entire college list, that is information for you to digest. That chat is not helping you anymore. You do not have to know what every other senior in town is doing. You do not need to know everybody else's stats.
Josh (28:12.738)
Yeah.
Lisa (28:39.68)
And you definitely do not need to bring somebody else's anxiety home and hand it to your own kid. Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do for your family is hit mute, put your phone down, and then walk away.
Josh (28:57.976)
That's some good sound advice, Lisa. Alrighty. Drop the Mic time. Last word. Lisa, you're up.
Lisa (29:00.814)
Thank you.
Lisa (29:04.45)
All right. Mine, still for parents. Shocker.
You have an amazing human sitting right in front of you. Do not let someone else's student make you forget that. I know I talked about that on my hot take, and I'm kind of talking about it here for Drop the Mic. I know it's easy to get pulled into this. You love your kiddo. You want them to have options. You want them to be happy. So you start looking around and making sure they are doing enough.
But your job is not to make your student's process look like somebody else's. Your job is to know your kid. Know what lights them up. Know when they need encouragement. Know when you need to stop asking them college questions and just watch a movie with them.
Because this process, y'all, it's temporary.
Your relationship with your kiddo is not temporary.
Do not let this admissions comparison take up more space in your house than it needs to.
Josh (30:14.498)
I like that. I like that the process is temporary, your relationship with your kid isn't, so don't let this process ruin it. That's good, Lisa.
Right. So mine is pretty simple. Nobody in the group chat gets a vote, and neither does Aunt Linda.
Now that doesn't mean you stop listening to people. Yes, ask questions. Yes, learn from other families. Yes, take the good advice.
Lisa (30:21.284)
Thank you. That's very high praise, Josh.
Lisa (30:34.403)
Linda.
Josh (30:44.148)
Somebody else's experience might teach you something you didn't know. But information is not a vote.
When it's time to make actual decisions, come back to your student. What do they want to study? Where can they actually see themselves living? What kind of campus feels right to them? What does your family realistically want to spend? And which schools give your kid options they would genuinely be happy to have?
Because the parent chat doesn't know any of that. Aunt Linda definitely doesn't know it.
So use the group chat for information. Use your relatives for support. But don't hand either one the steering wheel.
This is your kid's college process. Everything else is just noise.
Lisa (31:30.89)
One thousand percent. Hard stop. Okay?
Josh (31:34.336)
Okay, Lisa. We're gonna try this one more time. Next week on Drop In. Now we're going to Rome.
Lisa (31:41.96)
Yes, now we're going to Rome, y'all. Our conversation with Dean Zakina from Temple University Rome did get bumped for a week, but she is finally gonna be here.
And so remember, we're gonna be talking about starting college in Rome, whether that means the Temple Rome Entry Year or spending all four years there. And the best part, actually what it feels like to be 18 and figuring out your life in another country, just going to college abroad itself.
Josh (32:10.092)
Yeah, so basically college but with significantly better scenery.
Lisa (32:15.126)
Yes, 1000% again. So we will see you next week.
Remember, we are Decision Drop, making your college journey collaborative, simple, and most importantly, yours.
And if you want someone in your corner who knows your student, not somebody else's, to help build that list that fits them, tune out the noise, and get through decision season together, we'd love to help out.
So head to decisiondrop.com and check us out.
Josh (32:48.206)
Hey y'all, thanks for dropping in and we'll see you next week.
Lisa (32:50.69)
Yep. Bye. And don't forget to like and subscribe.
Josh (32:54.157)
I was waiting for that.

